The thread: Not a projection at all
Straight lines that are not
Everybody says the edges of a wide-angle frame bow. Nothing is special about the edge. A radial map moves every point along its own radius, so the only line it leaves straight is one through the principal point, and the bend of every other is decided by how far it passes from that one place.
Through water and glassWhat a ray does at a surface
A pool looks three-quarters as deep as it is — but only if you look straight down. At sixty degrees the same bottom appears at half its depth, and at eighty at a fifth, which is why the far end of a pool looks shallow enough to walk in.
The eye that movesA scroll is a camera that moves
A Chinese handscroll is not a picture with a wandering viewpoint or a picture with no viewpoint. It is the image of an eye that travels along a track and records one vertical line at a time, and that object has an exact geometry — orthographic along the roll, perspective across it.
Systems that kept the measureWhat the removed roof buys
The Japanese convention of drawing an interior with its roof lifted off is usually explained as a way of seeing inside. What it actually buys is uniformity — every room reports the same share of its floor, to the last sample, where the eye that frames the same building reports three different numbers.
Mirrors that are not camerasA curved mirror has no eye
A flat mirror is a second camera — reflect the eye in the plane and every line of sight passes through the reflected point, to 2.8e-12 mm. Curve the mirror and the point is gone. Over 20 cm of a mirror ball two metres across, the lines of sight miss their own best-fitting point by 2.8 mm, and by 52.9 mm on a ball half a metre across. What replaces the eye is not a worse eye; it is nothing.
The real instrumentA lens destroys the invariant
The cross-ratio is the one thing a projection preserves, and nearly everything checkable about a photograph is checked with it. A lens returns it one and a third per cent out where the pinhole is exact to fifteen digits — and the height error that follows tracks a quantity nobody would guess.
Through water and glassA picture through water has no viewpoint
Continue the rays of a refracted picture into the water and fit them to a common point. They miss it by ten millimetres. The same fit with the water taken away misses by zero, which is what makes ten millimetres a measurement rather than a number.
The eye that movesA straight line in a scroll is a hyperbola
Under a pushbroom the image of a straight world line is a Möbius function of the paper coordinate, which is a rectangular hyperbola. It is straight exactly when the line holds its depth — so a curve in a handscroll is a depth signal rather than a stylistic one, and the sag is computable in pixels.
Mirrors that are not camerasWhere the focus went
If the reflected rays do not meet at a point, they meet each other in pairs, and the curve they are all tangent to is what the mirror has instead of a focus. On a sphere of 1.6 m vertex radius it is 184.1 mm long and has a cusp; near the axis it sits at R/2, which is why a small enough spherical mirror passes for a good one. This is the bright shape in the bottom of a coffee cup, computed rather than admired.
Through water and glassWhat survives a pane of glass
A slab of glass moves every point of a picture and moves no direction at all. So the camera recovered from a photograph taken through a display case is exactly the camera that took it — out of a picture in which nothing is where it was.
The eye that movesThe centre a scroll does not have
Fit a common point to the rays of one section of a handscroll and it misses by metres. The miss is not a residual to be tightened — it is exactly the standard deviation of the eye's own track, it grows linearly with how much is unrolled, and it goes to zero only for a section of no width.
The rectangle behind the lensEvery row is a different camera
A shutter that reads its rows one after another images each of them from wherever the camera was at that instant, so a frame is a stack of projections indexed by height — a handscroll with the roll running down the picture. Its rays miss their own best centre by the spread of the eye's track, at a ratio of 0.988, and a global shutter's meet to 2 × 10⁻¹⁶ m.
Mirrors that are not camerasThe one shape that focuses
A paraboloid takes every ray parallel to its axis exactly through one point — 4.8e-9 mm of envelope across a 1.24 m aperture, which is arithmetic. A sphere with the same vertex curvature spreads the same bundle over 184.1 mm. So there is exactly one curved mirror that is a projection through a centre, it is a projection for exactly one bundle of rays, and every telescope in the world is built out of that sentence.
Through water and glassThe sky inside a cone
From under water the whole sky — every direction out to the horizon — arrives inside a cone of 48.61°. Outside it the surface is a mirror. That cone is a picture surface, and it has a distortion no surface in the curved field has — an area scale that runs to zero.
Mirrors that are not camerasA mirror ball is an equal-area fisheye
Photograph a mirror ball from far enough away and its rule is ρ = R·sin(θ/2), which is the equal-area fisheye — not an approximation to it, the rule. Measured, the departure falls from 4.27% of the picture's radius at 3 radii to 0.01% at 2000, while the next-best named rule stays 21% out at every distance. And the ball reflects 100.0% of the directions there are, which no designed surface does.
Systems that kept the measureA carpet and the people on it
A Persian miniature draws the ground as though from above and the figures standing on it as though from in front. The two views want optical axes exactly ninety degrees apart, and the plan view does not shorten a standing figure — it replaces its height with its distance from the point under the eye.
Through water and glassThe port that is not there
A flat window into water costs a lens a third of its field. A sphere centred on the entrance pupil costs nothing at all — not nearly nothing, exactly nothing — and six millimetres off centre costs 0.635°.
The eye that movesA scroll is not a panorama
Both draw straight world lines as curves, and one of them is a projection. A rotating eye keeps its centre exactly however far it turns; a translating eye has none at all. Curvature and centrelessness are independent properties, and conflating them is the standard mistake about both objects.
Mirrors that are not camerasThe cone that reads the floor
A conical mirror standing on a design turns it into a picture, and the map it performs is exact, one-to-one, and not a projectivity — a homography fitted to four of the marks returns those four to 7e-13 mm and puts the rest 2480 mm away, on a design 369 mm wide. The reason is that the cone turns the annulus inside out: the middle of the picture comes from the far edge of the floor and the rim from the near one.
Systems that kept the measureA picture with two eyes in it
Several traditions draw the floor from one place and the people on it from another. No single camera produces both, as an earlier essay showed. What such a picture actually is has a measurement attached: give the rays their world points and ask for the one place they all pass through, and at a stride of separation the best answer misses them by six tenths of a metre.
Mirrors that are not camerasA mirror ball does not know its size
The outline of a mirror ball in a photograph gives the ratio of its radius to its distance and stops there — a ball three and a half times bigger, three and a half times further away, draws an outline identical to the last bit. What breaks the tie is a point of the room, and only a near one: the sensitivity falls as one over the room's distance, so a mirror ball photographed against a landscape has no recoverable size at all.
Through water and glassThe dome knows its offset in units of itself
A dome port centred on the entrance pupil bends nothing at all, exactly. One that is not bends rays by an amount that depends on the decentring over the radius and on nothing else, so a ten-centimetre dome six millimetres off centre and a twenty-centimetre dome twelve millimetres off centre are the same instrument, bit for bit. The picture carries the ratio, which means it never carries the radius.
The real instrumentThe lens a pavement can hide
A photographed pavement reads as a correct drawing up to a radial coefficient of about four tenths — a lens strong enough to bow a straight edge across the page by nearly six pixels and to print as twenty per cent distortion at the frame's corner. The reason is that a pavement sits near the principal point, which is the one part of the frame a radial map barely touches.
Systems that kept the measureThe second eye is a shear
A picture drawn from two eyes is a picture drawn from one, of a different room. The map that puts the second eye away holds the picture plane still point by point and carries one centre onto the other, and the member of its family that matters turns out to be affine — a shear along the line joining the eyes, growing with depth, which is the same operation an oblique drawing performs.